Skip to main content

Daily News calls Adams’ ban of City Hall reporter unconstitutional, demands reversal

Daily News management is demanding Mayor Adams reverse his stated ban on the paper’s senior City Hall reporter from mayoral press conferences, calling the move a violation of The News’ constitutional rights.

An attorney for the paper made the demand in a letter sent to the city’s Law Department Friday.

“Banning [senior City Hall reporter Chris] Sommerfeldt from attending the Mayor’s press conferences is plainly unconstitutional,” attorney Matthew Leish wrote, citing both 1st and 14th amendment issues.

Leish asked the Adams administration to drop the ban by noon on Monday at the latest, and did not rule out further legal action. “[T]he Daily News and Mr. Sommerfeldt expressly reserve all of their rights and remedies,” he wrote.

As previously reported by The News, Adams banned Sommerfeldt from future press conferences on Tuesday after the reporter asked a question without raising his hand.

Reporters covering City Hall, including Chris Sommerfeldt at center, raise their hands to ask Mayor Eric Adams questions during an off-topic press conference at City Hall on Tuesday, Oct. 10, 2023. (Luiz C. Ribeiro for New York Daily News)
FILE - Reporters covering City Hall, including Chris Sommerfeldt at center, raise their hands to ask Mayor Eric Adams questions during an off-topic press conference at City Hall on Tuesday, Oct. 10, 2023. (Luiz C. Ribeiro for New York Daily News)

Sommerfeldt has not been called on by the mayor’s press staff in more than three months. The reporter had just asked a follow-up to another journalist’s question when Adams said: “You’re calling out a lot, Chris, stop calling out!” the mayor said in a sing-song tone. “You must have done that in school.”

“Listen, if he does that again, he’s not to come into our conferences,” Adams then said to his press staff.

Sommerfeldt then asked the mayor, “You want to take a question from me, then?”

“He did it again,” Adams replied. “Make sure security knows he’s not allowed back into this room.”

In his letter Friday, Leish, The News’ attorney, said the purported ban “unquestionably violates the First Amendment,” which prohibits selective regulation of the press.

“The Mayor’s press conferences are generally open to any credentialed journalist, and the purported reason for Mr. Sommerfeldt’s exclusion – the fact that he asked questions without being called on – is completely arbitrary given that other journalists have done exactly the same thing without incident,” Leish wrote.

The attorney said the ban also violated Sommerfeldt’s 14th Amendment right to due process to address the proposed ban.

Asked during a round table on the upcoming mayoral primary on WPIX Thursday about his plans, Sommerfeldt said he was going to continue “doing my job.”

Adams, asked if he planned to enforce the ban during a News 12 interview, said he expected there would be conversations between his team and Daily News management and that “we’ll decide what we’re going to do from there.”

City hall did not immediately respond to a request for comment.

The letter comes amid a groundswell of opposition to the ban.

The New York Press Club, the Freedom of the Press Foundation, and PEN America have all called on Adams to drop the ban, as has the Daily News Union. Republican mayoral hopeful Curtis Sliwa and Democratic candidate Zellnor Myrie also criticized Adams for the ban.



from New York Daily News https://ift.tt/l1VIdo6
via IFTTT
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

NYPD sergeant wounded in Bronx shooting released from hospital

The Bronx NYPD sergeant wounded during a harrowing police-involved shooting with an armed assailant was released from the hospital Saturday as a group of cops cheered him on. Sgt. Nicholas Novak humbly accepted the applause from the line of NYPD well-wishers as he left Jacobi Hospital , with his pregnant wife by his side. Novak, a 12-year veteran of the department, is currently assigned to the 49th Precinct’s Quality of Life Enforcement Team, or Q-Team, officials said. He and his wife are expecting their third child. NYPD Sgt. Nicholas Novak holds hands with his wife as he leaves Jacobi Medical Center in the Bronx on Saturday, Oct. 11, 2025. (Theodore Parisienne / New York Daily News) Novak suffered a serious head injury as he and his fellow officers grappled with an armed 18-year-old Antonio Morales, who had just fired off several shots as cops approached, officials said. The violent  confrontation erupted at the teen’s home on E. Gun Hill Road near Hone Ave. in Williamsb...
Post a Comment
Read more

Marathon hearings conclude in state case against Luigi Mangione for UnitedHealthcare CEO killing

Marathon proceedings in Luigi Mangione’s state homicide case came to a close Thursday, as Manhattan prosecutors and lawyers for the suspected killer of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson rested without calling any more witnesses. The parties won’t learn for some time which positions prevailed, with state Supreme Court Justice Gregory Carro asking each side to submit final written arguments and indicating he would rule on Mangione’s motions to suppress evidence central to the prosecution’s case by May 18. The hearings included 17 witnesses and centered on evidence recovered and statements Mangione made to Pennsylvania law enforcement surrounding his arrest five days after Thompson’s killing. Mangione was nabbed at a McDonald’s in the city of Altoona, more than 200 miles from the Hilton hotel in Midtown, outside which the CEO was shot dead Dec. 4, 2024. Notes allegedly found by police in Luigi Mangione's backpack after he was detained at a McDonald's in Altoona, Pennsylvani...
Post a Comment
Read more

Britain is lowering the voting age to 16. It’s getting a mixed reaction

By JILL LAWLESS LONDON (AP) — There has been a mixed reaction in Britain to the government’s announcement that it will lower the voting age from 18 to 16 before the next national election . The Labour Party administration says it’s part of a package of changes to strengthen British democracy and help restore trust in politics. The opposition says it’s a power-grab by the left. Experts say it’s complicated, with mixed evidence about how lowering the voting age affects democracy and election outcomes. The biggest change since the 1960s Britain’s voting age last fell in 1969, when the U.K. became one of the first major democracies to lower it from 21 to 18. Many other countries, including the United States, followed suit within a few years. Now the government says it will lower the threshold to 16 by the time the next general election is held, likely in 2029. That will bring the whole country into line with Scotland and Wales, which have semiautonomous governments and already let 1...
Post a Comment
Read more